
Postcode searches of crime and school stats can lead to "virtual segregation"
By Andy McCue
Published: 17 August 2005 16:00 BST
The proliferation of websites providing house buyers with information on good and bad neighbourhoods could widen the divide between the richest and poorest places in the UK, according to new research.
The report by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation warns that internet-based neighbourhood information systems (Ibnis) could lead to "online marginalisation" and "virtual segregation" of deprived areas of the country.
House hunters are currently able to use a number of commercial websites that feature information on schools and crime figures by postcode, while the government's own Neighbourhood Statistics site contains statistical, demographic and environmental information on neighbourhoods.
The report also warns that joke websites listing "crap" and "chav" towns create a negative image of the social characteristics of different areas.
Professor Roger Burrows, who led the research team from York and Durham universities, said he fears that US-style Ibnis websites, which allow users to search for neighbourhoods that match their prioritised criteria, will lead to virtual redlining of communities.
"It seems only a matter of time before the kind of powerful neighbourhood search sites available in the US start to reinforce the divide between the more and less prosperous locations in the UK," he said in the research.
Burrows said the situation is made more worrying because of the so-called "digital divide".
"Given what we know about the benefits of mixed-income communities in promoting social cohesion, it is important that greater public access to the 'social sorting' technology used by market research does not pull in the opposite direction and lead to even greater segregation between communities," he said.
The report advises that Ibnis websites should be made to specify their sources and state how the information was compiled, and that local people should be given the opportunity to challenge the way their neighbourhoods are being portrayed.
The aim of the government's Neighbourhood Stats pr...
Simon Dickson
This exposes the fundamental flaw in the governmen...
Anonymous
What on earth is "virtual redlining"?
Please, i...
Justin Wheatley
I've recently moved house and I greatly appreciate...
Hamish McCallum
and the alternative option is being told, or direc...
Bryan Scott
The scope of our development projects is vast and hence you can expect a truly varied role, working on projects such as cutting edge eCommerce ...
Experience of implementing and supporting complex software, particularly high volume websites or transactional systems. The CGO team is part of the ...
Senior ASP.Net Developer sought by our client, a leading producer of innovative websites and applications for learning and personal development and ...
CIO Agenda 2008
The exclusive silicon.com CIO Agenda 2008 survey looks at the CIO's tech shopping list for the year, examines whether IT budgets are rising or falling and reveals what the pain points are for tech chiefs this year. Find out more in our latest special report.
Stories from the web...
Copyright ©1995-2008 CNET Networks, Inc. All rights reserved. Top of page
Howard Greenfield Tech Futures: The talkification of the web A software switch gives browsers a voice...
Natasha Lomas 'Green' technology can't save us from ourselves So much for the rhetoric...