You are here: silicon.com > Networks > WebWatch

WebWatch

Google to keep top-ranking anti-Semitic websites

Right to free speech or just plain insensitive? Google stands by its rankings

By Jo Best

Published: 14 April 2004 16:15 GMT

Google has defended its stance over the anti-Semitic website that tops its rankings, saying that however distasteful the site may be, it will have to stay to preserve the ranking system's objectivity.

It's the search results for the word "Jew" that are causing all the problems for the online giant – the site that ranks first is anti-Semitic Jewwatch.com, which links to other anti-Jewish sites and lists various supposed Jewish conspiracies.

Google has publicly declared that it finds the site distasteful, but because the company's rankings are determined by algorithms and not people, Google believes that removing the offensive site will call into question the search engine's objectivity. Its current policy is only to intervene in cases where a site's content is illegal.

The legal niceties of the situation, however, vary from country to country. While the Jewwatch site may be allowed under the US's constitutional First Amendment right to free speech, the German and French versions of Google won't show the site in any search results due to legislation banning race-hate websites.

Although Google says it has no plans to take down the site, anti-Jewwatch websites and petitions have been created, calling for the site's removal and demonstrating the strength of feeling surrounding the issue. The email forwards that have been circulating on the internet this week have been requesting 50,000 signatures to force Google to change its mind. That target was beaten yesterday.

Google, however, maintains that no amount of signatures will lead to a change of heart. Sergey Brin, Google's founder and Jewish himself, told Reuters that he found the site offensive but didn’t believe the site should be taken down.

"I certainly am very offended by the site but the objectivity of our rankings is one of our very important principles," he said.

  1. Zones
  2. Management
  3. Networks
  4. Software
  5. IT Services
  6. Hardware
  1. Verticals
  2. Public Sector
  3. Financial Services
  4. Retail & Leisure
Read and write about internet access at the airports of the world at atlarge.com. Rate airports, and see what others have to say...

Natasha Lomas Exclusive: Jimmy Wales on what's next for Wikipedia Why Wikipedia needs geeks and why a life unplugged is unthinkable

Peter Cochrane Peter Cochrane's Blog: United breaks guitars? Customer service has changed forever


  • Jobs
SAP SD/EDI CONSULTANT - WEST COUNTRY - 45-50K + BENS- GLOBAL BRAND

SAP SD consultant for market leader in the West Country. You will requires strong hands on SAP SD configuration/implementation and support ...

Web Developer / PHP Developer- Joomla or Magento CMS - Google Accredited Agency

PHP Web Developer / PHP Programmer - Joomlaor Magento CMS - Google Accredited AgencySlough, BerkshireUp to 28,000We are one of Berkshire's leading ...

Country Car Stock Manager

Responsibility for car stock management on all branches in the country A country level position in a young and friendly team Our client a ...

Agenda Setters 2009
Welcome to the ninth annual Agenda Setters poll – silicon.com's list of the top 50 most influential individuals in the technology and IT industries, from techies and CIOs to entrepreneurs and business leaders. Find out more in our latest special report.





Quick Sitemap Links: