
Vodafone goes for tit-for-tat approach to complaints
By Jo Best
Published: 9 November 2005 17:10 GMT
O2 has found itself on the wrong end of an adjudication from ad watchdog the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) after rival operator Vodafone filed a complaint.
Vodafone's gripe with the recently acquired company relates to an O2 ad campaign.
O2 press adverts claimed "Best ever UK mobile network performance beating all national call success rates previously published by Oftel" within a specified period.
Vodafone filed an objection to the campaign saying call success rates were not enough to justify a claim on 'best ever network performance'; that Vodafone had beaten O2's 99.2 per cent call success rate; and that the ads would make people think O2 had a stronger signal than other networks.
The watchdog didn't uphold the last complaint but backed Vodafone's other grievances, saying the audit methodology on call success rates used by O2 and Vodafone made it impossible to say who could boast of being the best.
The ASA also concluded that being the best network depended on more factors than call success, including network coverage and capacity. It said: "We concluded 'Best ever UK mobile network performance' was too wide-reaching a claim to be substantiated by merely an operators' call success rate. We told O2 not to make the claim on the basis of its call success rate."
The advertising watchdog also told operators to be carefully of making claims about superiority unless they can be "unquestionably" backed up.
The spat is not the first time the pair have faced off through the ASA. O2 recently complained to the regulator about Vodafone's 'best bar none' campaign. That complaint was also upheld.
Computer Futures is looking for a Campaign Evaluation Analyst to join one of the UK's largest organisations for a 6 month conract. You will be ...
Regional Sales Manager Telecoms / Mobile Network Operator 45-57k Basic; OTE 90-100k Car / Car allowance plus corporate benefits North Central / North ...
Demonstrate in-depth knowledge of mobile network technology and network operator processes Our client a leading global telecoms and mobile services ...
Agenda Setters 2009
Welcome to the ninth annual Agenda Setters poll – silicon.com's list of the top 50 most influential individuals in the technology and IT industries, from techies and CIOs to entrepreneurs and business leaders. Find out more in our latest special report.
Stories from the web...
Copyright © 2008 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved. Top of page
Natasha Lomas Exclusive: Jimmy Wales on what's next for Wikipedia Why Wikipedia needs geeks and why a life unplugged is unthinkable
Peter Cochrane Peter Cochrane's Blog: United breaks guitars? Customer service has changed forever