
Bandwidth dreams and nightmares for ISPs
By silicon.com
Published: 16 August 2007 11:09 GMT
Claims by ISPs that the BBC should fund the extra bandwidth needed by users that want to download content from its online TV service iPlayer seems a little out of touch.
Tiscali says as the BBC is responsible for the content and the distribution service, it sees no reason why the corporation shouldn't fund the extra bandwidth that users will be using.
As one silicon.com reader pointed out - ISPs wouldn't even exist if it wasn't for the content people want to access on the web.
Cheat Sheets
♦ Web 2.0
♦ Mash-ups
Downloading of rich video content is only going to grow over the next few years and ISPs will need to be able to cater for this. If ISPs can't cope, they're not going to last much longer in the changing online landscape.
The specific issue seems to be that iPlayer is a peer-to-peer system so that it uploads and downloads data at the same time, making it potentially bandwidth-heavy.
Added to this, the programmes take around half an hour to download so a lot of bandwidth is used over a sustained period of time.
But to charge a content provider to distribute material just because it takes up more bandwidth cannot be justified in the long term. More and more services will appear which demand as much, if not more, bandwidth and so perhaps one day soon the demands of the iPlayer will seem positively thrifty.
With the number of users for iPlayer likely to be ramped up over the coming few months it's really down to the ISPs to adjust so their customers can make full use of what the service has to offer.
Eventually, ISPs will have to accept they need to offer greater bandwidth and download limits so customers can use the growing number of services but for now some at least may continue to stick their heads in the sand.
Sure, the ISPs might work on thin margins for consumer broadband. But there is certainly a sense that now the iPlayer has arrived, something that might actually make consumers want to use the high speed home broadband they have been sold, that the ISPs are turning round and asking for more money.
It's not an argument that's going to impress businesses out there working on the next big thing - be it a media player or a website - that demands lots of bandwidth. They won't want to pay the ISPs for the extra bandwidth used and nor should they. If ISPs were allowed to tax content providers in this way it would have a chilling effect on the industry.
Consumers have been sold a fully fledged broadband service at a set price and if that service can't handle the rich video content users want to see then it's a problem for the ISP and its pricing structure, not the BBC.
The ISPs have sold the broadband dream - now they must make sure it doesn't turn into a nightmare.
We pay for our bandwidth already so what the hell ...
Anonymous
Why pick on the poor old BBC ? Channel 4's VOD and...
Anonymous
Historical model;
- ISP buys wholesale xDSL capac...
Haydn Rees
I must be stupid - isn't the BBC paying for upload...
Joe Whitehead
I get 8GB/month from my ISP and I can pay for more...
Glen Monks
C# 3.5, WCF, WPF, SQL - Fund Management. Opportunity to join a growing fund management specialising in long-only fund management and alternative, ...
This is not a role for your typical artistic GUI developer, you must have best amongst peer tech skills and a track record of designing and ...
For this role, a good understanding of computer networking systems and architectures is important, (such as Peer-to-Peer and Client/Server models, ...
Agenda Setters 2009
Welcome to the ninth annual Agenda Setters poll – silicon.com's list of the top 50 most influential individuals in the technology and IT industries, from techies and CIOs to entrepreneurs and business leaders. Find out more in our latest special report.
Managing a growing threat: An Executive's Guide to Web Application Security
5 Sources of Value Through a Telecom Expense Management Initiative
Adopting Server Virtualization for Business Continuity and Disaster Recovery
Business Continuity and Disaster Recovery with CA Recovery Management and VMware...
Stories from the web...
Copyright © 2008 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved. Top of page
Peter Cochrane Peter Cochrane's Blog: How the telcos could save themselves Doomed network operators could thrive with a bit of innovation
Peter Cochrane Peter Cochrane's Blog: Facebook saves teen from prison Another unexpected impact of social networking